Counterproductive Taxes Proposed During Earnings Slump

The White House released its 2011 budget proposal today, containing several new taxes on the oil and natural gas industry.

Among the administration's proposals are tax hikes on:

  • Domestic oil and natural production amounting to about $36.5 billion;
  • Dual capacity and international tax changes estimated at $8.5-12 billion;
  • Repeal of the LIFO (last-in, first-out) accounting practice, which is likely to cost the industry between $23-26 billion; and
  • The reauthorization of Superfund, which could cost oil and natural gas companies approximately $9.4 billion.

These tax increases could add roughly $80 billion to the industry's tax bill, making the production of oil and natural more expensive. And they're being proposed at a time when the effective tax rate for the industry has been around 53 percent as opposed to 32 percent for the rest of the S&P Industrials (2008--most recent data available).

As API's President and CEO Jack Gerard said today, "Imposing new taxes would reduce our nation's energy security by discouraging new investment in domestic oil and natural production and refining capacity and pushing those investments--and American jobs--abroad."

The administration's tax hikes were announced just as several energy companies were releasing their earnings reports for the past year, indicating the oil and natural gas industry did not keep pace with other industries.

2009earnings.jpg

With seven major oil and natural gas companies reporting their earnings so far, the industry earned on average 4.8 cents per dollar of sales in both the 4th quarter and all of 2009. In comparison, the Dow Jones Industrial Average companies have reported earnings of 10.2 cents per dollar sales of the 4th quarter and 9.5 cents for the entire year with 21 of the 30 companies reporting to date.

Rather than raising taxes, the economy could be better served by allowing the oil and natural gas industry to make investments in additional domestic energy supplies. If the industry were given access to areas that have been off-limits, it could create hundreds of thousands of jobs and generate revenues in the form of royalty payments and leasing fees to federal, state and local governments.

Comments

Related

Blog Posts

For Fair Disclosure

On its face, a federal provision requiring oil and natural gas companies to be transparent about what they pay to foreign government...

Blog Posts

Royalties and Fair Shares

Great post by the American Enterprise Institute’s Steven Hayward (similar version posted on Powerline), breaking down a recent study...

Blog Posts

‘Poisoned’ Politics, the Keystone XL and the Nation...

New York Times op-ed columnist Joe Nocera’s piece on the “poisoned” politics of the Keystone XL pipeline decision is a must read. Be...

Blog Posts

Energy Works in Minnesota

For the state of Minnesota, the oil and natural gas industry currently means: More than 117,000 jobs – with an average salary o...

Blog Posts

Energy Works in Colorado

Here’s what the oil and natural gas industry currently means to the state of Colorado: $20.5 billion contributed to the economy...

Blog Posts

Blogger Conference Call – SOTU Follow Up

Last week, API hosted a blogger conference call to follow up on President Obama’s State of the Union remarks. API Senior Tax Policy...

Blog Posts

Political Theater on Refined Exports

One of the flimsier arguments deployed against the Keystone XL pipeline is that the Canadian oil sands crude it would deliver to U.S...

Blog Posts

More Evidence of the Keystone XL Consensus

New polling on the Keystone XL pipeline shows consensus in America isn’t always elusive. The United Technologies/National Journal Co...

Blog Posts

Energy Works in Florida

Here’s what the oil and natural gas industry currently means to the state of Florida: More than $18 billion contributed to the...

Blog Posts

Just The Facts: No Targeted Oil & Gas Tax Credits

Oil and natural gas opponents think they’ve got some ammunition in a NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll from nearly a year ago showin...

Blog Posts

Energy and the State of the Union

There were lots of energy mentions in the president’s State of the Union speech, and we appreciate every one of them because they li...

Stay Connected